Sacramento, CA·Unclaimed

CarMax

Reputation intelligence powered by AI

C

0/100

Reputation Score

Reputation Score: 61/100

Weighted composite of 4 factors:

Rating (×40%)85 pts
Response Rate (×30%)15 pts
Sentiment (×20%)60 pts
Volume (×10%)100 pts

171 reviews across 3 platforms:

Google113
Yelp48
DealerRater10

Subscribe to see all platforms

Rating
B4.1

Average Rating: 4.1

Reviews analyzed171
Median rating5★
Factor score85/100

≥4.5 → A · ≥4.0 → B · ≥3.5 → C · ≥3.0 → D · <3.0 → F

171 reviews across 3 platforms:

Google113
Yelp48
DealerRater10

Subscribe to see all platforms

Response Rate
F14%

Response Rate: 14%

Reviews with reply28
Total reviews171
Factor score15/100

≥80% → A · ≥60% → B · ≥40% → C · ≥20% → D · <20% → F

171 reviews across 3 platforms:

Google113
Yelp48
DealerRater10

Subscribe to see all platforms

Sentiment
C59%

Sentiment: 59%

Positive46
Neutral83
Negative42
Factor score60/100

AI-analyzed tone and context across all review text.

171 reviews across 3 platforms:

Google113
Yelp48
DealerRater10

Subscribe to see all platforms

Volume
A2412

Review Volume: 2412

Factor score100/100

≥100 → A · ≥50 → B · ≥20 → C · ≥10 → D · <10 → F

171 reviews across 3 platforms:

Google113
Yelp48
DealerRater10

Subscribe to see all platforms

Rating Distribution

5
9556%
4
127%
3
64%
2
127%
1
4627%

4.1

Average

Average Rating: 4.1

Total reviews171
Median rating5★

171 reviews across 3 platforms:

Google113
Yelp48
DealerRater10

Subscribe to see all platforms

63%

4-5 star

High-Rated Reviews: 63%

5-star95
4-star12

Percentage of reviews rated 4 or 5 stars.

34%

1-2 star

Low-Rated Reviews: 34%

2-star12
1-star46

These reviews most impact purchase decisions. Responding can recover up to 33% of dissatisfied customers.

4.1★

Rating

Average Rating: 4.1

Total reviews171
Median5★

171 reviews across 3 platforms:

Google113
Yelp48
DealerRater10

Subscribe to see all platforms

2,412

Reviews

Total Reviews: 171

171 reviews across 3 platforms:

Google113
Yelp48
DealerRater10

Subscribe to see all platforms

Higher volume improves SEO and credibility.

14%

Response Rate

Response Rate: 14%

With reply28
Total171

Percentage of reviews with an owner response. 80%+ is the benchmark.

59%

Positive Sentiment

Positive Sentiment

Positive46
Neutral83
Negative42

AI-analyzed sentiment from review text.

C

Overall Grade

Overall Grade: C

≥90 → A · ≥75 → B · ≥60 → C · ≥40 → D · <40 → F

61

Score (out of 100)

Score: 61/100

Rating (×40%)85 pts
Response (×30%)15 pts
Sentiment (×20%)60 pts
Volume (×10%)100 pts

Cross-Platform Ratings

Google

4.1★

2,412 reviews

DealerRater

4.6★

71 reviews

BBB

B

0 reviews

Yelp

1★

598 reviews

See how this dealership rates across Google, DealerRater, BBB, and Yelp — all in one view.

14-day free trial · $99/mo after · Cancel anytime

Monthly Performance

MonthReviewsAvg RatingResponse RatePositive %Δ Reviews
Apr 202600
Mar 20260-4
Feb 202642.3★25%25%-7
Jan 2026114.7★0%0%+2
Dec 202593.8★22%11%-3
Nov 2025124.7★8%83%0

Review Analytics

Sentiment Breakdown

171total
Positive
4627%
Neutral
8349%
Negative
4225%

Review Velocity

Last 12 months

0

This month

11

Monthly avg

131

Annual

Reputation Opportunities

Quick wins identified from your public data

Respond to more reviews

Your 14% response rate is below the 80% threshold that customers expect. Dealers who respond to 80%+ of reviews see 15% higher conversion rates.

Close the rating gap

At 4.1★, you're 0.4 stars below the top tier. Each 0.1★ increase can improve click-through from Google Maps by up to 9%. AI sentiment analysis pinpoints the specific issues dragging your score down.

Stay ahead of 23 local competitors

The local average is 4.5★. Get actionable insights to close the gap and outrank competitors.

Competitive Landscape

Benchmarked against 23 local competitors

AI-Detected Patterns

Poor Communication & Unresponsiveness

18mentions

Vehicle Quality Issues Pre Delivery Inspection Failures

12mentions

Our AI identified 18 mentions of "Poor Communication & Unresponsiveness". Unlock the full report.

14-day free trial · $99/mo after · Cancel anytime

Recent Reviews

Showing 10 of 171

1/10

Responded

Response Rate (Shown)

With reply1
Shown10

Of the reviews shown on this page, how many have an owner response.

1

Positive

Positive Reviews

Reviews classified as positive by AI sentiment analysis of review text.

3

Negative

Negative Reviews

Reviews classified as negative. These require immediate response to mitigate damage.

3.6★

Avg Rating

Average Rating (Shown)

Average star rating of the 10 reviews displayed on this page.

M

Mark F.

Feb 15, 2026

positive

Sold our car today. Stressless, seamless and easy and got the amount we hoped for. A great place to buy a car and a great place to sell one.

E

Eric Lodge

Feb 13, 2026Responded

negative

This place actively made it very difficult to purchase a car. Despite having made a reservation to buy a car, and arriving 15 minutes prior to my reservation, I was not helped for over an hour despite countless staff out on the sales floor clearly with spare time on their hands. I came in ready and willing to purchase a car. In fact, a luxury $40K+ vehicle. The customer service, or lack thereof, made me take my business elsewhere.

Dealer Response

We appreciate you posting a review for our store. We aim to deliver an exceptional experience that is hassle-free for you as our customer, and we take your feedback to heart. We're grateful that you provided us with these details so we can explore how to continue improving our service in the future.

J

Jeremy B.

Feb 13, 2026

negative

Rude employee Sam just stared me and my girlfriend down while checking out a new car and was asking how I will afford this and had energy of assuming I won't buy it and my girlfriend felt very uncomfortable walking in front of him.

H

Hannah T.

Feb 9, 2026

negative

Last update: The situation was resolved with a buyback. I dealt with it from September of 24' to February of last year. I have had to replace a few things with the car that I got switched out, but ultimately it works far better. We're done with service #3 now with the same exact issues as when I started. It's now also making an odd noise when idling. The customer service has improved but the actual work done has not. I now have to take my car directly to Honda for service and potentially to another mechanic for a diagnostic service. Go somewhere else for a car. You'll be dealing with them for months on end with no resolution. Before you consider going to CarMax Sacramento, PLEASE explore all your other options. I strongly recommend NOT using CarMax at all. If you fall in love with a car they're selling, get it sent to the Roseville location, where you'll deal with more respectful and competent employees. Every person I spoke to made at least one mistake. First, every single person failed to update my phone number and email address even though I asked, so they kept sending paperwork to the wrong places. I was also misquoted for my trade-in. Although I had trouble with insurance (which wasn't their fault), I sent the updated info to multiple people, yet they kept asking for documents I had already provided. Finalizing the paperwork was a hassle because they still didn't update my contact info correctly. Even after the keys were brought out, they forgot to remove the trackers, so the employee had to go back and fix that. The center console was wobbly and broken. After just 3-4 hours, I heard a clicking noise and had to call them back, where I dealt with a very rude representative who clearly wanted me off the phone. After regrouping, I called again, and she was rude again. They offered me a rental, which I took because I didn't want to risk damaging the car so soon after getting it. Upon closer inspection, I found a random device bolted under the steering wheel with a frayed wire that had been taped over--something they should've caught before selling me the car. Not sure if they did it or not. When I arrived to pick up the rental, they asked again for my temporary ID, which I had already given them multiple times. To make matters worse, they still had the canceled insurance policy on file, despite me sending the new information to multiple people. They then informed me the soonest repair appointment was the 26th and they couldn't adjust my car payment date, meaning I'll be without my car for two weeks while still paying for it. Not just that, I wrote that the device was underneath the steering wheel, told them multiple times it was underneath the steering wheel, and was still asked twice if it was under the center console. Evidentially they don't properly file paperwork or communicate back there. The rental itself was filthy, with French fries left inside, and it wasn't even filled up all the way. It also guzzled gas, which was too expensive for me, so I went back to exchange it. When I arrived, an employee rudely asked me, 'So where's the car?' as if I had done something wrong by not pulling it all the way in, which I wasn't instructed to do. She sounded genuinely mad and offended. The second rental is better on gas but has squeaky brakes, smells sour like marijuana when it sits in the sun, is dirty with trash between the seat and console, and one of the two key fobs don't work. The speakers crackle. They advised me their rentals are cars off of their lot. It's shocking they were trying to sell this car to someone in such bad condition. I hope my car is done sooner than the 26th because this has been the worst customer service experience I've ever had. Almost every employee I interacted with needs retraining, especially on communication and basic manners. Bottom line: Take your business somewhere else, or at least go to the Roseville location where you won't have to deal with these issues. Editing to add on because somehow this situation has gotten worse: I was contacted yet again for paperwork THEY HAVE BEEN GIVEN MULTIPLE TIMES. I still don't have a fully functioning car after service, they did practically nothing to it, only removed the wire and didn't actually look into the problem of my car. I have my next appointment on the 26th and if my problems are not resolved, then I'm going to be filing a complaint with Department of consumer affairs. Please, everyone be very informed about who you are purchasing from.

M

Michael Breen

Jan 31, 2026

Excellent service and staff. The vehicles can be a bit disappointing but there are unicorns if you know what your looking for. Definitely worth the trip.

B

Brad Watson

Jan 27, 2026

R

Rob W

Jan 23, 2026

B

Brad Garner

Jan 23, 2026

Colin was very nice and professional. Transaction was seamless.

K

Kelijo Boney

Jan 22, 2026

We went it to sell/trade our ‘08 Yaris but reserved an Outback to test drive just in case and went home with the Outback. This is the second car we’ve bought from this location and like last time, it was a great experience. Before purchasing, we went over a list of items we wanted repaired and verified it’d be covered in the warranty. Our sales rep, Mercedes, wrote everything down and double checked a few things before making any promises. Once we were all good to go, she walked us through all the trade in and purchase paperwork. It was easy, and took just a couple hours. Genuine, no pressure buying experience. I can’t imagine spending a whole day at a regular dealership when Carmax exists. We bought the car when it was dark outside so the following day we noticed a couple other little things and made the call to see about adding some more items to our repair list and there was zero pushback. Easy breezy and we got our repair appointment scheduled.

L

Loly Ramirez

Jan 15, 2026

They are just awesome..Alondra is the best🩷

AI-Powered Response Management

M

M.

Feb 15, 2026

positive

This review contains detailed feedback about the dealership experience including sales process, pricing, and customer service quality that would be very helpful for the owner to read.

Subscribe to read

AI Response Available

Thank you for sharing your experience. We value your feedback.

E

E.

Feb 13, 2026Responded

negative

This review contains detailed feedback about the dealership experience including sales process, pricing, and customer service quality that would be very helpful for the owner to read.

Subscribe to read

AI Response Available

Thank you for sharing your experience. We value your feedback.

J

J.

Feb 13, 2026

negative

This review contains detailed feedback about the dealership experience including sales process, pricing, and customer service quality that would be very helpful for the owner to read.

Subscribe to read

AI Response Available

Thank you for sharing your experience. We value your feedback.

Unlock AI-drafted responses for 143 unanswered reviews and manage your full review history.

14-day free trial · $99/mo after · Cancel anytime

Take Control of Your Reputation

Start responding to your 143 waiting reviews today.

14-day free trial · $99/mo after · Cancel anytime

Claim this dealership

Unlock reviews, AI responses & insights